Submissions Close Soon on TCDC Mangrove Bill

I have just sent away my Submission to Parliament’s Select Committee on the ludicrous Thames Coromandel District Council Local Bill in which they seek the unprecedented power to rip out mangroves anywhere they like without a resource consent.

You can make a submission here – please do so. Submissions close on 23 February.

Forest and Bird have a submission form here

I suspect the Select Committee does not want to hear argument for and against mangroves. But they will be making a recommendation to Parliament as to whether the existing law under the RMA is sufficient to deal with these issues. In other words, talk about the process, rather than the merits of mangrove removal or retention.

the main points I made it are –

if this Bill were passed it will allow the councils to ignore

  • an international treaty – Ramsar,
  • the highest level planning law – the New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement,
  • the RMA and every other law that applies to the coastal environment, and even their own District Plan

it would set a totally unworkable precedent.  If passed many other councils in the country will be rushing out a local Bill to advance their particular pet project and circumvent the RMA.  The result – utter chaos.

the existing laws are actually working fine. Consents have been granted for removal of mangroves under the RMA in the Whangamata harbour and elsewhere

the so-called “community concern” about mangroves is overstated. Since the January 5 storm surge and Thames flooding, people have come to realise that mangroves provide a highly effective buffer against storm surges and sea-level rise, and are wanting the mangroves retained

the Council has shown its bias on the issue and cannot be trusted to independently assess these issues

there would be no appeal rights – the Council is setting up a kangaroo court as judge and jury

the Bill is simplistic — it deals with the effect but not the cause of mangrove expansion

the issues are highly complex – the councils do not have the resources or technical expertise to properly assess these issues

The Select Committee should recommend to  Parliament that the Bill be ditched and not proceed any further.

An interesting article on the Bill on the Newsroom website. It is extraordinary the lengths the TCDC have gone to prevent Forest and Bird Society getting access under the Official Information Act to its internal correspondence and legal advice about this Bill.  More here 

 

Advertisements

One thought on “Submissions Close Soon on TCDC Mangrove Bill

  1. Denis thanks for your good work on this … your ongoing efforts to make this area a better and more sustainable place to live deserve high praise and I sincerely hope that many will follow your lead on this issue. To this end I’m wondering if it might be helpful to supply a few brief cut and paste points for time poor people who may like to make a submission opposing the bill .. but feel a bit daunted by this ?

    For example : 1) If this Bill is passed it will allow TCDC to ignore an international treaty – Ramsar; the highest level planning law – the New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement; the RMA and every other law that applies to the coastal environment, and even their own District Plan.

    2) If passed many other councils in the country will be rushing out a local Bill to advance their particular pet project and circumvent the RMA. The result – utter chaos. 3) The Bill is simplistic. It deals with the effect but not the cause of mangrove expansion.

    4) Since the January 5 storm surge and Thames flooding, people have come to realise that mangroves provide a highly effective buffer against storm surges and sea-level rise, and are wanting the mangroves retained.

    5) The existing laws are working and we have evidence of this with consents being granted under the RMA for Whangamata Harbour and elsewhere.

    waiorongo (denise) davis

    Like

Comments are closed.